I had the Five Fish Experience and the oysters — both were absolutely outstanding! The oysters were large, fresh, and delicious, and their mignonette was divine. The Five Fish meal was generous and perfectly prepared.

What truly made the evening unforgettable was the service. Laura went above and beyond — I’ve never felt so well attended to. The hostesses were also wonderful and welcoming, even taking my coat upon arrival. From start to finish, everything exceeded my expectations. The Five Fishermen definitely did not disappoint!

– Chanel Romagna

My husband and I just celebrated our anniversary and Valentine's Day at The Five Fishermen, and we couldn't be happier! From the food to the service, it was great. Our waitress gave excellent menu recommendations and was kind and attentive. We would recommend this place – especially for special celebrations!

– Cindy T

We dined at Five Fishermen for Valentine’s Day. We were seated right on time for our reservation, which we appreciated, especially on a busy night.

We ordered the rib eye steak, frutti di mare pasta, and seafood chowder. The steak was okay, but for the price, it didn’t really stand out compared to other restaurants. The pasta was good and I enjoyed it, though it also didn’t feel particularly special. The seafood chowder was a bit watery for my liking, but the flavor itself was really good.

We understand it was a Valentine’s rush, but the service felt a little slow. A party that arrived about 10–15 minutes after us ended up receiving their food at the same time as ours. For a date night, it also felt like a missed opportunity not to have something small and thoughtful included, even just a simple Valentine’s touch.

Overall, the vibes were nice and definitely date-night appropriate. We just expected a bit more, especially considering we paid around $200 for one steak, one pasta, one soup & 2 cocktails.

– Kim D